Assured Property Investments Assured Property Investments
  1. Current Listings
  2. Past Developments
  3. News & Guides
  4. Customer Stories
  5. About Us
  6. Contact
07 823 2525
Author John Kenel22 July 2019

Expert Opinion

Why NZ House Prices won’t follow Australia

Here’s an excerpt from Tony Alexander’s Weekly Overview that’s well worth reading:

Forecasts of a collapse in New Zealand house prices have been made repeatedly since the 1980s and were most prevalent during and immediately after the GFC. None of these forecasts have proved correct. Average prices fell only 11% between 2007 and 2009 and have risen 88% since then. Nonetheless, focussing on a comparison with Australia, since 2003 while Australia’s Capital Cities House Price Index has risen by 90%, NZ’s nationwide index has risen by 150%. New Zealand ranks as one of the world’s least affordable housing markets.

Here are some reasons suggesting it is not valid to extrapolate recent declines in Australian house prices into the NZ scene.

  • Housing Stock Growth
    One reason for the difference in price growth since 2003 is that although Australia’s 27% population growth since 2003 exceeds NZ’s 22%, Australia’s housing stock has grown by 30% versus just 20% in NZ. In NZ there is a housing shortage which is getting worse, whereas in Australia there is a (temporary) oversupply.
  • NZ Shortage Worsening
    In the past 5 years NZ’s population has grown by 458,000. At an average household occupancy rate of 2.7 people per dwelling, this required 170,000 net extra houses to be built. Actual dwelling stock growth was only 126,000. The NZ housing shortage is growing and will continue to do so as net migration flows are remaining high near 50,000 (1% of population) per annum.
  • Debt and Debt Servicing
    Between 2003 and 2019 the household debt servicing ratio in Australia rose from 8.2% to 9.1%. NZ’s ratio has fallen from 9.1% to 7.6%. Australia’s household debt to income ratio has jumped from 134% to 190%, NZ’s has risen from 130% to 164%.
  • Foreign Buying
    There has never been as great a level of foreign house buying in New Zealand as Australia. The official NZ data start only in 2016 but show average non-resident buying of 2.5% of all sales, falling now to 0.6%. In Australia, according to an NAB quarterly survey, foreign buying peaked in 2014 near 16% for new properties and 9% for existing ones. Fewer than 4% of existing dwelling sales now go to foreigners and 5% of new dwellings.
  • Apartments versus Houses
    Since 2003 67% of dwellings built in Australia have been in multi-unit developments. The NZ proportion is just 26%. Prices for apartments have historically shown greater volatility than prices for houses.
  • SMSFs
    In New Zealand there was no surge in people gearing compulsory superannuation money into housing as occurred in Australia, (given the absence of self-managed superannuation funds) and therefore no recent strong downward pressure on prices from the cessation of bank lending for such.
  • Stamp Duties % Offshore Owner Levels
    There are no stamp duties on dwelling purchases in NZ therefore there is an absence of the recent depressing price effect in Australia from states introducing and still increasing duties and levies on foreign buyers and owners.
  • Interest-Only Lending
    In 2015 in Australia near 40% of lending to households was interest only. In NZ at the same time the proportion was 28%. Due to the imposition of new restrictions this ratio in Australia now stands near 20% versus 26% in New Zealand.
  • Construction Constraints
    The most recent annual number of dwelling consents issued in NZ is 34,500 or 1.8% of the housing stock. In Australia the number is 190,285 and the proportion 1.9% – still greater than in NZ even after a fall from 230,000 a year ago. There is a shortage of builders across all trades in New Zealand – partly because shortages offshore have attracted some Kiwis away for higher incomes and opportunities.
Author John Kenel22 July 2019
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • #assured-news
  • #expert-opinion
  • #finances
  • #investment-strategy
  • #new-zealand
  • #supply-and-demand

More news

Economy

Author John Kenel21 January 202101 Jan 2021

Savers are losers

This is a favourite saying by Robert Kiyosaki and it’s the unfortunate...

Read more

Economy

Author John Kenel18 January 202101 Jan 2021

NZ house prices continue to rise

December stats show that the national median house price has risen to...

Read more

Economy

Author John Kenel11 January 202101 Jan 2021

Biggest tenancy law reform in 35 years: ‘I’ll keep my places empty’

My interview in the NZ Herald today. Tenancy law changes will have...

Read more

Featured properties

Apartment

$0

2 new apartments available!

High Yield – 13 Crescent Court – Waikato Hospital

Bedrooms 1
Bathrooms 1
Carparks 1

Apartment

$0

New apartments next to Waikato Hospital

Very high yields and positive cashflow – must sell!

Bedrooms 1
Bathrooms 1
Carparks 1

Townhouse

sold

2, 3 & 4 Bedroom Townhouses

Studio Homes on Te Rapa – SOLD OUT

Bedrooms 3
Bathrooms 3
Carparks 2

Assured Newsletter

Be first to know about
new developments

free

new

The Hamilton Property Guide

2020 issue edited by John Kenel, Assured Property

Download free
  • Home
  • Current Listings
  • Past Developments
  • News & Guides
  • Customer Stories
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Visit

63a Alpha Street, Cambridge
Monday - Friday (9am - 5pm)

Contact

info@assuredproperty.co.nz 07 823 2525

© 2021 Assured Property Investments. 

Site by Brontë + Benek